Brother HL-L2370DN: Keep or Dump?
Is the Brother HL-L2370DN worth keeping in 2025, or is it a money pit? We've crunched the numbers on ink costs vs new printer prices. Here is our honest verdict based on real UK pricing.
Compare Your Options
See how Standard, XL, and upgrading compare for your printing needs
Standard Cartridges
Best for occasional printing and lower upfront costs
XL / High-Yield
Maximum value with lower cost per page for regular printing
Upgrade Printer Option
Consider a new printer for better long-term value and features
HP OfficeJet Pro 9022e
A versatile all-in-one inkjet printer designed for small businesses and home offices. Offers fast printing, automatic duplex, and wireless connectivity.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Standard | XL/High-Yield | Upgrade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Approximate cost per page | ~3.0p | ~2.3p | Varies |
| Approximate upfront cost | £35.99 | £69.99 | £250.00 |
| Approximate pages per cartridge | 1200 | 3000 | N/A |
| Best for | Occasional use | Regular printing | Long-term savings |
Verdict: UPGRADE (Money Pit Warning)
If you print regularly, the Brother HL-L2370DN is likely costing you a fortune. Our data shows you could save over £100/year by switching to a more efficient printer. It's time to upgrade.
Analysis Summary
For a Brother HL-L2370DN printing around 250 pages per month, estimated ink costs are roughly £39.10/month (approximately £469.20/year, based on typical retail prices and yields). Upgrading to a Epson EcoTank ET-2850 could reduce estimated monthly ink costs to around £0.63/month, and the upgrade could pay for itself in around 4 months, assuming similar usage.
Reasons to Keep It
The Brother HL-L2370DN makes sense to keep if:
- You print VERY occasionally (<5000 pages/month)
- You are happy paying a premium for convenience
- The printer is fully functional and meets your quality needs
Reasons to Dump It
You should DUMP the Brother HL-L2370DN if:
- You print consistently (> 5000 pages/month)
- You feel like you are constantly buying ink
- Switching to Epson EcoTank ET-2850 puts £38.48/month back in your pocket
- Switching to Epson EcoTank ET-2720 puts £38.48/month back in your pocket
- Check our Smart Upgrade Advisor for a personalized calculation
Better Alternatives
Based on typical usage (around 250 pages per month), here are smarter printers to buy:
- Epson EcoTank ET-2850 — only ~£0.63/month to run
- Epson EcoTank ET-2720 — only ~£0.63/month to run
Get Personalised Advice
Note: This is guidance only — always check full details and prices with retailers before deciding. All cost estimates and recommendations are approximate and based on typical UK retail prices and yields. Actual costs and payback periods may vary depending on where you shop, current deals, your printing patterns, and supplier pricing. Use the Smart Upgrade Advisor for personalised advice.